Morgan E. Schutz
ENG 251: The Personal Essay
Professor Nicholas
3 February 2008
At the Heart of the Game
I grew up in Pine Bush, N.Y., a tiny town that up until a few years ago didn’t even appear on most maps. My mom and dad were always having me try new sports and encouraging me to try out for teams. I made most of the teams I ever tried out for—I can’t actually remember not making a team. I remember my first swim team try-out. I was in 4th grade and scared out of my wits by the bigger kids who were swimming in the lane next to the lane that I was being asked to “show what I could do” in. I jumped in feet first and swam as fast as my arms could bring me down the lane without stopping. I hit the wall, pushed off on my back, and did the same mad-sprint to the wall, this time backstroke. When I finished, the first 50 I had ever swam in my life, I looked up at the coach, and he handed me an official Pine Bush Piranhas swim cap. I was the only one of the 20 of us trying out that day who received a cap. I was hooked.
[The enormous building reverberates with the echoing sound of applause and cheering coming from the stands. The upper stands are filled with family members and friends, the lower stands jam packed with the athletes—each team in their own section of bleacher, with their matching uniforms and banners waving high. It’s an intense scene for the spectators, let alone us athletes and coaches on deck.
Rutger’s University in New Jersey is host to the Metropolitan College National Collegiate Athletic Association’s Swimming and Diving Championships this weekend. It is the last weekend in February, and this meet is the culmination of the 2006-2007 season.]
I’ve been a swimmer for as long as I can remember. My mom tells stories of how much I hated pools as an infant—crying and kicking to get as far from the watery basin that she would dangle me above. That fear and apprehension as a baby quickly disappeared as my mom enrolled us in Mommy and Me swim lessons. By the time I was 4-years old I could swim pretty well on my own, but the swim lessons continued and after I had made my way through the Red Crosses 6 levels of swimming in record speed, it was time to declare myself a swimmer and join a swim team.
12 years of competitive swimming later, here I am, at the end of my junior year of college, a particularly trying season with many disappointments, with one last chance to prove myself to myself.
[The Olympic sized pool pans out in front of spectators and athletes alike, its glassy water stretching a full 50m in length and 8 lanes wide. A bulkhead in the middle, creating two equally intimidating, 25-yard pools breaks the pool. Earlier today, the whole pool had been in use, but now, during the finals, only the front pool is housing competition. After three days of competition the building smells strongly of mildew and latex caps mixing repulsively with the heavy aroma of chlorine—a smell that will take weeks of showering to be rid of for good. The nervous emotions of the swimmers on deck, with their warm-ups zipped up over their necks and mouths, their eyes on the pool and their legs shaking instinctively as if keeping rhythm with their anxiously beating hearts, are only amplified by the knowledge that every eye in the facility is on those 8 lanes.
My event has just ended, I climb out of lane 8 slowly, breathing hard and looking up at the scoreboard. My time is unimportant really, it’s not a great time, but it’s the best time I’ve done all season. I quickly gather my things, avoiding the swimmers awaiting their upcoming races, and their nervous dance of jumps, stretches, fidgets and suit rearranging and head towards the far side of the pool where my coach will undoubtedly be standing. I can see he is holding his clipboard in one hand and spinning a pen through the fingers of the other. As I approach, he turns towards me sharply:
“Why did you even bother going out there?” he says snidely, “you might as well have scratched and let one of the alternates have a chance to go out there and actually prove something.”
“What?” I ask, thinking he must be joking, “I dropped a whole second from the prelims this morning! I thought that was a pretty good swim, considering.”
“Considering what?!”
“Considering how I’ve swam so far this meet, I guess.”
“You think that was giving it your all?” he snarls, “One good time doesn’t mean you’ve given it your all, or that you’ve tried your best.”
“I know I left everything I had in that pool. I did everything you told me to—I kept my head down, and I didn’t breathe into or out of the walls, I gave it everything I had left. ” My smile has disappeared, a hostile stare moves across my red, tired face.
“Really?” His eyes dart back onto the pool rather than me.
“Yes, really. My legs are dead, I’m exhausted—it’s been a long meet and yeah, that was all I had to give.”
“Well clearly we’re going to have a problem here. If you’re not going to have any heart when you go out there and swim then get the fuck off the deck.”
The shock of his accusation and his language takes my breath away and for a moment, I say nothing. I stare at the pool, where another event is just ending—the swimmers still in the pool examining their times and placing on the large score board hung high above the pool.
“No, heart?” I ask dejectedly.
“You heard me. If you’re going to come over here after an embarrassing swim like that and say, you gave your all, then you don’t need to ask what I am talking about.”
“Are you kidding me? No offense coach, but maybe you didn’t notice, that’s the best time I’ve done all season. I know it’s not great. I’m not jumping for joy over the fact that I swam horribly this year, but I’m not gonna let you ruin the best thing I’ve done all season. Look around, I know I’m not the one without heart on this team.”
His eyes stay on the pool, his face a little redder than before, but perhaps just from the balmy, heat of the pool deck. When it is clear, he isn’t going to say anything further, I brush past him and head back towards the teams spot in the bleachers. I wonder if I said too much, if I went past that line of appropriateness. ‘Oh well, only one more year left’ I think as I climb back into my spot on the crowded bench, ‘it can’t be any worse than this one.’]
I’ve never hated swimming more than I hated swimming that night. Even during the hardest of practices, the worst of meets, I never truly hated what I was doing. Athletes learn a lot of things about themselves during their competitive years, and for me, the one thing I had learned most resoundingly about myself, was that I had heart.
As a senior in high school, I was signed to swim Division I at a big school in Maryland. I was excited and nervous to swim for the same team that Michael Phelps would occasionally coach. However, a few months before graduation, I was talking with my orthopedic surgeon, who I had been seeing for several years due to shoulder problems. She warned me that I would never finish my first year of Division I swimming, and probably ruin my shoulders beyond repair if I didn’t have reconstructive surgery on both shoulders beforehand. Its tough realizing your dreams crushed. I scratched all plans of swimming at Loyola College that fall and stayed home—attending a local school for my freshman year and had both shoulders shaved, gutted and rebuilt. A few months, several thousand dollars, countless hours of physical therapy and I was good as new and back in the water, I knew I had heart.
That year was what I had assumed would be my most trying year as a swimmer—I essentially had to learn to swim again. If I could get through that, I could get through anything I thought. And, I did, I set six school records at Mount Saint Mary College that year and I came back with vengeance: my times were faster, my strokes were smoother and my determination to make a name for myself at the collegiate level was stronger than ever.
I transferred to The College of Saint Rose as a sophomore on a swimming scholarship with plans to be better and faster than I had ever been before, and for a while, I was. Things went south my sophomore season for whatever reason and that final blow at the end of the season was devastating. As I left that meet, I wasn’t sure I would ever step foot on the Saint Rose pool deck again. But, I did. The funny thing about having heart is that it is not something you can turn off or ignore, regardless of how battered it might get along the way.
You learn many things as an athlete; some of these things help you to be a better person (time management, work ethic, and goal setting to name a few), some of these things make you a better person. My coach never apologized for his accusation, not then and not now as I finish my senior, and final season, but when you love something, you don’t really need that do you? No need for someone’s apology or justifications—you know what you have and what you love. I suppose it’s true that sometimes the blow that knocks you to the ground is just what you need to learn to stand up on your own.
*I’ve also attached this document to an e-mail I sent to the classes strose account, that might be easier for printing purposes*